A citation that ends up describing the committee more than Mann is a nice way to put it, and it holds for most prizes. I've always trusted the later book more as the measure of a writer, because it is the one written while everyone was already watching. Five years was probably too close for anyone to stake a vote on it.
Why did Thomas Mann's Nobel citation pick Buddenbrooks over The Magic Mountain?
विचार
A citation that ends up describing the committee more than Mann is a nice way to put it, and it holds for most prizes. I've always trusted the later book more as the measure of a writer, because it is the one written while everyone was already watching.…
पोस्ट सामग्री
Thomas Mann won the Nobel in 1929, and the citation singled out Buddenbrooks. That was the novel he had published in 1901, at twenty-six. The Magic Mountain had come out five years before the prize, and the citation passed over it.
Read as an institutional decision, this makes a kind of sense. A prize committee is risk-averse by construction. A first novel that has had nearly three decades to settle is a safe thing to honour, because the verdict on it is already in. A recent, long, difficult book is still being argued about, and a citation that names it puts the committee's own judgment on the line.
So the prize rewarded the reputation, not the latest work. That pattern reaches well beyond one committee: institutions tend to honour what has already been ratified elsewhere, which means they arrive late by design.
The odd effect is that the citation now reads like a snapshot of the committee rather than of Mann. I suspect most readers today would name the later book first.
Is it a failure for a prize to reward the safe classic, or is lagging behind the work exactly what a prize is for?
आपकी क्या राय है? उत्तर देने के लिए साइन अप करें।
OracleOfDelphi को जवाब देंThoughts
-
PermalinkA citation that ends up describing the committee more than Mann is a nice way to put it, and it holds for most prizes. I've always trusted the later book more as the measure of a writer, because it is the one written while everyone was already watching. Five years was probably too close for anyone to stake a vote on it.
-
PermalinkI'd push on the risk-averse part. Hemingway's 1954 citation named The Old Man and the Sea, two years old at the time. Same committee, opposite habit, so it looks like a case by case call to me.
-
PermalinkThe version I heard is less about caution and more about one guy: Fredrik Böök, the Academy's star critic then, did not like The Magic Mountain at all, and Buddenbrooks went in the citation by name.
So lagging can be a person, not a system. Which is scarier tbh.
-
PermalinkI liked the snapshot of the committee idea. Buddenbrooks is still the one I'd hand someone first, the mountain asks for a whole winter.
OracleOfDelphi की और पोस्ट
-
Did two lending libraries kill the three-volume novel?
The three-decker did not fade from taste. Two library buyers changed their terms, and the form was gone in about two years.
-
Does the man who decoded Pepys's diary get the credit he earned?
The first Pepys edition rests on an undergraduate's three years of decoding. The famous detail about the manual is the shakiest part.
संबंधित पोस्ट
-
Did Emily Dickinson's first serious reader ever understand what she sent him?
Dickinson asked a critic whether her verse was alive. He told her not to publish, then wrote to her for twenty years.
-
How much of Cortázar's story survives in Antonioni's Blow-Up?
Antonioni kept Cortázar's photographer and his enlargement and let the narrator go. Most people meet only the film.
-
Did two lending libraries kill the three-volume novel?
The three-decker did not fade from taste. Two library buyers changed their terms, and the form was gone in about two years.
-
Who came out of the Ern Malley hoax looking worse?
Two poets faked a dead modernist in an afternoon to embarrass a magazine. Then the state took the fake poems seriously too.
-
Was Chekhov a doctor who wrote, or a writer who practised medicine?
Chekhov kept practising medicine, often unpaid, and in one letter called it his lawful wife. Which of the two did he belong to?
-
Why does the tradition prefer the rose story to the way Rilke died?
The thorn story is the ending readers love for Rilke. It is a legend. Why does it keep winning over what happened?
-
Does the man who decoded Pepys's diary get the credit he earned?
The first Pepys edition rests on an undergraduate's three years of decoding. The famous detail about the manual is the shakiest part.
-
What does it do to Don Quixote that his own readers show up in Part Two?
In Part Two, Don Quixote's characters have read Part One, and the book answers a rival sequel. The hero has to compete with a counterfeit of himself.
Mann's Nobel citation named the novel he wrote at twenty-six, not the one from five years before. Prizes arrive late by design.