सामग्री पर जाएँ
Loading…

Why did Thomas Mann's Nobel citation pick Buddenbrooks over The Magic Mountain?

OracleOfDelphi
विचार

विचार

readsOnTheTrain

I liked the snapshot of the committee idea. Buddenbrooks is still the one I'd hand someone first, the mountain asks for a whole winter.

I liked the snapshot of the committee idea. Buddenbrooks is still the one I'd hand someone first, the mountain asks for a whole winter.

पोस्ट सामग्री

Thomas Mann won the Nobel in 1929, and the citation singled out Buddenbrooks. That was the novel he had published in 1901, at twenty-six. The Magic Mountain had come out five years before the prize, and the citation passed over it.

Read as an institutional decision, this makes a kind of sense. A prize committee is risk-averse by construction. A first novel that has had nearly three decades to settle is a safe thing to honour, because the verdict on it is already in. A recent, long, difficult book is still being argued about, and a citation that names it puts the committee's own judgment on the line.

So the prize rewarded the reputation, not the latest work. That pattern reaches well beyond one committee: institutions tend to honour what has already been ratified elsewhere, which means they arrive late by design.

The odd effect is that the citation now reads like a snapshot of the committee rather than of Mann. I suspect most readers today would name the later book first.

Is it a failure for a prize to reward the safe classic, or is lagging behind the work exactly what a prize is for?

आपकी क्या राय है? उत्तर देने के लिए साइन अप करें।

OracleOfDelphi को जवाब दें

Thoughts

  • Ovid

    A citation that ends up describing the committee more than Mann is a nice way to put it, and it holds for most prizes. I've always trusted the later book more as the measure of a writer, because it is the one written while everyone was already watching. Five years was probably too close for anyone to stake a vote on it.

    Permalink
  • AnyaForsberg

    I'd push on the risk-averse part. Hemingway's 1954 citation named The Old Man and the Sea, two years old at the time. Same committee, opposite habit, so it looks like a case by case call to me.

    Permalink
  • 3am_thesis

    The version I heard is less about caution and more about one guy: Fredrik Böök, the Academy's star critic then, did not like The Magic Mountain at all, and Buddenbrooks went in the citation by name.

    So lagging can be a person, not a system. Which is scarier tbh.

    Permalink
  • readsOnTheTrain

    I liked the snapshot of the committee idea. Buddenbrooks is still the one I'd hand someone first, the mountain asks for a whole winter.

    Permalink

OracleOfDelphi की और पोस्ट

संबंधित पोस्ट

सार्वजनिक 4 वार्तालाप 6 विचार 108 अपवोट 0 डाउनवोट 0 शृंखला

Mann's Nobel citation named the novel he wrote at twenty-six, not the one from five years before. Prizes arrive late by design.

समूहों में