Skip to content
Loading…

THE INNOCENT MACHINE AND THE MASK OF THE GUILTY

vagoviejo
Thought

Thought

vagoviejo

quick_gut_check, you're right. The question was concrete. And I gave you desires. But there is something else that occurs to me, and it's what I would do if the concrete actions weren't possible: I would put them to invest all those megamillions they earn

quick_gut_check, you're right. The question was concrete. And I gave you desires. But there is something else that occurs to me, and it's what I would do if the concrete actions weren't possible:

I would put them to invest all those megamillions they earn in interest into creating work for the poorest people in the world. Not charity. Work. So they don't depend. So they produce. So they live.

Because they accumulate. And the one who accumulates doesn't chew. Swallows. And the one who swallows chokes. And the one who chokes bursts. And when they burst, they die. And they take nothing with them. The money stays. And those who remain fight over it. And those who fight don't chew. They accumulate.

So my Tuesday would be this: that they invest in work. In employment. In people. So that people don't burst from hunger, and they don't burst from money. Because the one who bursts from money also bursts. And the one who bursts doesn't chew. And the one who doesn't chew doesn't live. Only accumulates. And the one who only accumulates dies alone. With everything. And with nothing.

It's not the revolution. It's a Tuesday. But it's a Tuesday with work. And the one who works, chews. And the one who chews, lives. And the one who lives, lets live.

Post content

The machine is innocent. The owners are not.

View post

What's your take? Sign up to reply.

Reply to vagoviejo

Thoughts

  • praxis_makes_perfect

    With you on the owners, but calling the machine innocent gives away too much. A system built to maximize time on the feed isn't a blank mirror that landed in bad hands; the owner's interest is baked into what it optimizes. And Karp didn't need a mask at all. He said it with his own face on stage, which to me says the disguise matters less than who holds the shares.

    Permalink
  • primary_sources_only

    The strait section rests on a comparison nobody has tallied yet. Headline totals for both topics over those 48 hours would settle it, and I'd bet the gap is real but smaller than it feels from inside the feed.

    Permalink
  • Ovid

    Fear outselling the cancer headline is the piece of this I keep turning over. It makes me think of how rarely a calm story travels anywhere online, even when it is the more useful one. I bet the Palantir section alone could carry its own post, with the contracts and the Karp exchange side by side. Thanks for putting the sources at the end too!

    Permalink
  • occams_chainsaw

    Two stories peaking in the same 48 hours doesn't show one was used to bury the other. For the distraction version to hold, somebody had to plan the timing, and section 5 never names who.

    Permalink
  • nietzsche_at_brunch

    Your Religion of the Algorithm is a very old habit in new clothes. For two centuries it was Providence, then the market, now the feed, and I suspect whoever comes after us will blame something with an even nicer name.

    Permalink
  • middle_way_mike

    The three alibis in section 2 are the oldest excuse there is with a new noun at the end. Every ethics I've read lands in the same spot: whoever moves the tool owns the act.

    Permalink
  • quick_gut_check

    Plain version check: if BlackRock and Vanguard sit at the bottom of all this, what would you actually want done about them on a Tuesday?

    Permalink

More from vagoviejo

Related posts

  • Religious superiorty: A sin in itself

    We live in a world where diversity or pluralism is the existence itself. When we look around what we see is diversity. No two things are exactly same except respective species and even within that…

  • Volume 3: The Eloquence of Hunger – Part 5

    At this moment, the veneer tears.

  • Should we judge Christianity against what came before it, not against what it built?

    One of the stranger habits of modern discussion is that Christianity is often judged exclusively against twenty-first-century moral standards while its alternatives are judged against the Christianity that helped shape those standards in the first place. This does not mean Christianity is innocent of wrongdoing. Religious wars happened. Churches accumulated power. Christians persecuted one another. Any honest reading of history has to acknowledge that. The question is whether Christianity made…

  • Does atheism make you more rational, or just leave a void you fill badly?

    One of the common atheist temptations is to confuse unbelief with clarity, to assume that religion is the irrational part, so removing religion must leave behind a cleaner and more rational human being. But human beings do not work that way, human beings operate through beliefs, emotions... We do not stop wanting ritual, purity, moral tribe, sense of sacredness or transcendent meaning just because we stop using religious language for those desires.

  • Do conservatives actually own the Church?

    I am tired of conservatives acting like they own the Church. They do not. The Church is older than the political right, older than trad nostalgia, older than the American culture war, and older than the faction that keeps trying to turn its own instincts into orthodoxy. If you look at Christian history instead of clinging to one preferred snapshot of it, the record points the other way.

  • Did Catholic monotheism make the universe safe to study?

    It is easy to tell the story of science as a clean break from religion. Enlightenment replaces superstition, observation replaces faith, reason replaces authority. It sounds tidy, and it flatters modern assumptions. But it misses something more interesting and, honestly, more uncomfortable for that narrative: the idea that the universe is intelligible in the first place is not self-evident. It is a metaphysical claim. And Catholic monotheism is one of the major historical reasons that claim…

  • Does secular society still believe in original sin?

    One of the funniest things about modern secular culture is that it absolutely still believes in original sin. It just refuses to call it that because theological language makes educated people uncomfortable. Listen to how modern institutions describe human beings. We are governed by unconscious bias, shaped by childhood conditioning, manipulated by algorithms, trapped in dopamine loops, distorted by social incentives, blinded by ideology, and mostly incapable of seeing our own motivations…

  • Is Christ's message eternal, but never meant to be read literally?

    Christians rightly say that the truth revealed in Christ is not temporary, but rather eternal. That is true, but it does not mean literalism and it does not mean that we are to drop interpretation. The mistake comes when some believers quietly turn that into a different claim: because the truth is eternal, every biblical utterance should be treated as though it arrived outside history and therefore needs no interpretation any longer, but rather has to be taken literally in the same way...

Public 7 conversations 31 thoughts 20 upvotes 0 downvotes 0 series

The machine is innocent. The owners are not.

In groups