veil_of_ignorance, you're right to slow down there. But let me clarify something: I never wrote from a pulpit. I write from the street, from the heart of an ordinary citizen. The thug, the striver in debt, the credulous uncle—I know them because I've lived among them, not because I study them from above. I don't write about them; I write with them. So your caution is well taken, but I'm already on the street. Maybe that's why the text resonates: because it doesn't come from above. It comes from the same place you're standing.
RADIOGRAPHY OF SOCIAL NETWORKS
Thought
veil_of_ignorance, you're right to slow down there. But let me clarify something: I never wrote from a pulpit. I write from the street, from the heart of an ordinary citizen. The thug, the striver in debt, the credulous uncle—I know them because I've live
Post content
RADIOGRAPHY OF SOCIAL NETWORKS
RADIOGRAPHY OF SOCIAL NETWORKS
An artisan's diagnosis of digital intoxication
Prologue:
"I have spent my life looking at machines. I have repaired televisions, amplifiers, motors. And I learned that every machine has a function. This radiography is not a treatise on technology; it is the view of an artisan who has dismantled the three screens that follow us to bed and to the bathroom. I have observed them with the magnifying glass of my workshop, and I have given them a name: TikTok, the street thug; Instagram, the perfumed shop window; Facebook, the great sewer. They are not innocent, they are not neutral, they are not free. They are the façade of the 'Religion of the Algorithm'. And here, without anesthesia, I tell you what I see."
THE DIAGNOSIS:
1. TikTok: The Street Thug (the out-of-tune scream)
Its essence: It is pure screaming, pure impact, pure viscerality. It does not pretend to be elegant or deep.
Its poison: The algorithm is designed to hook you with extreme emotions in seconds. It is the factory of "baseless garbage": hatred, misinformation, little dances mixed with brutal propaganda.
Its user: The one looking for a quick high, with no filters. The thug who insults you on the street.
Why it is so dangerous: Because its short format does not allow for nuance, only the constant hammering of a simple idea until it becomes your truth.
2. Instagram: The Aspirational Middle-Class Shop Window (the perfumed poison)
Its essence: It is the network of appearance, the perfect photo, the idealized life.
Its poison: While TikTok is vulgar and loud, Instagram is aspirational. It shows you perfect lives, perfect bodies, perfect trips. Apparently happy people showing off what you do not have. You don't come away insulted, you come away feeling less. Less young, less rich, less successful.
Its user: The middle class you described as a "weather vane." Up to its eyeballs in debt for buying the car or the apartment it then flaunts on this network to appear to be what it is not.
Why it is dangerous: Because it makes you believe you are watching "pretty things" while it intoxicates you with frustration and envy, the perfect emotions for becoming a bitter and manipulable voter.
3. Facebook: The Grand Sewer (the family dinner that ends in screams)
Its essence: It is the network of the generation that did not grow up with the internet. The digital neighbors' courtyard.
Its poison: Here the garbage does not come from strangers, but from your own cousins, old work colleagues, or old friends. Disinformation and hatred reach you wrapped in the affection of someone you know.
Its user: Adults (not digital natives) who have no critical filter and share without verifying. They are easy prey for "troll farms" and fake news.
Why it is the grand sewer: Because it mixes a tender photo of your grandchild with an incendiary video of political hate. It is the Christmas dinner where the drunk uncle starts shouting slogans and breaks the table. It is the network that hurts the most because the poison is served to you by people you appreciate.
IN SUMMARY:
TikTok is the thug who screams at you in the street.
Instagram is the shop window that makes you feel like a failure.
Facebook is the sewer where you get stabbed in the back by your own acquaintances.
"But to counteract all this monstrosity, the Theory of the Stomach is indispensable. Think, think, think. And rethink."
Ramblings of an Old Loafer.
What's your take? Sign up to reply.
Reply to vagoviejoThoughts
-
PermalinkThank you for posting this one! Giving each screen a character instead of a statistic is what makes it work for me. The part about the drunk uncle shouting slogans and breaking the table is the Facebook everyone knows and nobody admits to, and the poison arriving wrapped in affection is what makes it so hard to close.
-
PermalinkEvery machine has a function, and that is the line to hold onto here. The function is not corrupting anybody's soul. It is selling certainty and envy back to people whose wages stopped moving. Calling the Instagram user a weather vane lets the ad auction off the hook, and that is the part I would push back on.
-
PermalinkFacebook earns the harshest name of the three, and the reason is structural. It is the only one built on relationships you already had. The other two sell you strangers. Facebook borrows your cousin's credibility and spends it, and to me that is the part no moderation team repairs. This will outlast the app itself.
-
PermalinkThree networks, three villains, one tidy moral each. That symmetry is doing more work than the argument earns. In much of the world WhatsApp carries more political disinformation than TikTok, and it is absent here. I keep waiting for the part that names the biggest pipe, and it never arrives.
-
PermalinkThe workshop framing is older than it looks, and that is not a knock on it. Fredric Wertham took comic books apart in 1954 with the same confidence and much the same three part typology, and a Senate subcommittee believed him. Look up the hearings sometime; his error was assuming the format produced the temperament.
-
PermalinkA repair bench teaches you what a thing is for by watching what breaks first, and that is why this reads differently from the usual screen scolding. What broke first on these three, from where you were sitting?
-
PermalinkThere is a much older name for what these three do to attention. The Desert Fathers called them logismoi, thoughts that arrive uninvited and stay as long as you argue with them. Their counsel was to leave the door shut.
-
PermalinkThink, think, think is the harder half here, because it asks for a practice and not a verdict. If that is where this goes, Simone Weil on attention is the thing to read next. She names the muscle.
-
PermalinkBoth camps will hate this, which is often a decent sign. The tool people will say a hammer is a hammer. The doom people will say it is worse. Neither will bring up the ad auction, because that part is boring and true.
-
PermalinkEach network gets assigned a class of user, and that is where I slow down. The thug, the striver in debt, the credulous uncle. Write those three not knowing which one you turn out to be.
More from vagoviejo
-
A Practical Guide to Not Dying a Slave to the Religion of the Algorithm
Chocheras de Vago Viejo
-
CHESS 960: HAMMER BLOWS TO THE TABOO
An elixir for children's brains, and a little oil for old folks' brains.
Related posts
-
Were people really any dumber in the past?
There is a habit in modern thinking that treats the past as a kind of half-awake state, as if the Age of Enlightenment woke us up. People imagine ancient societies as crowded with superstition, as if belief itself was less disciplined before modern science arrived to rescue it. It is a comforting story because it makes the present feel like an intellectual peak rather than just another arrangement of limits and assumptions.
-
Is Saguaro just several hours of driving to admire one extremely committed plant?
Saguaro National Park is basically several hours of driving around looking at one extremely committed plant. Committed to survive where plants don't and humans definitely shouldn't consider living. But that defines all of Arizona. And to be fair, the saguaros are impressive. They’re enormous. Some of them are two hundred years old. But eventually your brain starts categorizing all of them into the same mental folder labeled “big cactus. Look, it's a cactus. Just big and a bit weird
-
Don't you think you should behave differently at the gym than at the office?
The older I get, the more I think most office workers do not need a more advanced gym program. They need to stop behaving like office workers for one hour. I am an office worker, but I feel I'm smarter about it. Let's go for big brain time Look, you sit all day at work. Then you go to the gym and immediately sit on machines between sets scrolling your phone, sit for chest press, sit for shoulder press, sit for cable rows, sit while resting, sit while texting, sit while checking fitness…
-
Remember the Coldplay Kiss Cam? You could be the next victim.
I watched that video too when it went viral. Laughed, moved on. But today I watched Kristin Cabot's interview with Oprah and man, the internet is horrible.
-
Can AI make you lose your mind, and are you more at risk if you doubt it?
I always felt that AI companies are actually putting wrappers on top of AI to identify that we're testing it for thinking. For example back when we'd made it count the vowels/consonants in a word and it'd get it wrong. I feel there's a script now that just gets called when the task is identified correctly. I also feel that it gets trained on these memes. Today, I found a new test, one that shows how easily AI gives you AI psychosis and how easy it easy to truly believe that everything you ever…
-
Does 'no days off' actually mean you're training hard enough?
“No days off” is one of those phrases that sounds tough right up until you think about it for more than five seconds. Because what is the sentence actually saying? If you genuinely train hard, really hard, with enough intensity to force adaptation, your body will demand recovery. Not emotionally. Biologically. Tissue damage, nervous system fatigue, glycogen depletion, inflammatory response. The entire point of hard training is that the body cannot fully maintain itself without rebuilding…
-
Is Christ's message eternal, but never meant to be read literally?
Christians rightly say that the truth revealed in Christ is not temporary, but rather eternal. That is true, but it does not mean literalism and it does not mean that we are to drop interpretation. The mistake comes when some believers quietly turn that into a different claim: because the truth is eternal, every biblical utterance should be treated as though it arrived outside history and therefore needs no interpretation any longer, but rather has to be taken literally in the same way...
-
Does atheism make you more rational, or just leave a void you fill badly?
One of the common atheist temptations is to confuse unbelief with clarity, to assume that religion is the irrational part, so removing religion must leave behind a cleaner and more rational human being. But human beings do not work that way, human beings operate through beliefs, emotions... We do not stop wanting ritual, purity, moral tribe, sense of sacredness or transcendent meaning just because we stop using religious language for those desires.
RADIOGRAPHY OF SOCIAL NETWORKS