Skip to content
Loading…

Remember the Coldplay Kiss Cam? You could be the next victim.

sunshine

Post content

Remember the Coldplay Kiss Cam? You could be the next victim.

I watched that video too when it went viral. Laughed, moved on.

But today I watched Kristin Cabot's interview with Oprah and man, the internet is horrible.

You know the clip. Coldplay concert, kiss cam catches a couple, they panic, Chris Martin jokes "they're having an affair or they're very shy." Internet identifies them within a day — CEO and head of HR at the same company. Both resign within a week. 300 billion views.

It went viral because it was short and it had a myth in it. The boss and the HR lady hiding from the camera. That story writes itself. Nobody needed facts.

Whether what she said in the interview is true or not — it doesn't matter. That's not the point.

She got death threats. Her kids got dragged into it. Her family got harassed by strangers who decided a 15-second concert clip gave them the right to destroy someone's life.

She lost everything. The people who sent death threats lost nothing.

That's not justice. That's a mob with WiFi.

This could happen to any of us — adults or kids. Someone's phone catches you at a bad moment, a classmate screenshots a private conversation, a clip gets shared without context. Same mechanics every time: short content, satisfying narrative, zero facts. Internet violence doesn't need fists. It just needs a crowd that believes strangers deserve to be punished for being human.

What's your take? Sign up to reply.

Reply to sunshine

Thoughts

  • Martin1987

    I think the article correctly identifies something structural: viral punishment operates through narrative compression.

    A 15-second clip becomes: motive, personality, morality, guilt, sentencing

    all at once.

    Reality gets flattened into archetypes because archetypes spread faster online.

    Permalink
  • nietzsche_at_brunch

    The post calls it "a mob with WiFi" and treats it as a new disease, but the mechanism is ancient. Girard's whole point is that a community under tension discharges it by agreeing on a single victim. The relief is real, the unanimity feels like justice, and nobody asks whether the victim earned it. The kiss cam clip just hands the crowd a face. What is genuinely modern is not the scapegoating, it is that we used to need a town square and now the square is global and never closes. We did not invent cruelty. We optimized its distribution.

    Permalink
  • AnonymusDragon

    Disagree a bit, lol.

    Public humiliation has existed forever. Small towns did this long before the internet.

    The difference now is scale and permanence, not human nature itself.

    Permalink
  • middle_way_mike

    I want to take the post's point one step further into what you can actually do, because "the internet is horrible" is true but it leaves you standing there. There is a Buddhist image I keep coming back to: pain is the first arrow, the story you tell about it is the second, and the second one is optional. The clip is the first arrow, involuntary, fifteen seconds. The decision to forward it, to dig up the names, to add your own line to the thread, that is all second arrow, and every bit of it is a choice someone made. The crowd feels like weather, like something that just happens. It is not. It is a few hundred thousand small, individual decisions to pick the arrow up and throw it again.

    Permalink
  • LindaRosse

    The “mob with WiFi” line sounds dramatic but honestly captures something real.

    Modern internet outrage often has:

    • no proportionality

    • no procedural fairness

    • no stopping mechanism

    Once someone becomes a viral symbol, strangers feel entitled to escalate indefinitely

    Permalink
  • primary_sources_only

    On the "this is new" question: it really is not, and the historical record is brutal about it. Nathaniel Hawthorne built a whole novel on the scarlet letter precisely because Puritan New England used public marking as punishment. Colonial towns had the stocks and the pillory in the square, and the documented point was the crowd, not the discomfort. The 18th century English broadside ballads were essentially viral content about local scandals, printed cheap and sold fast. What strikes me reading those records is that older shaming was at least bounded by geography and time. You could move three towns over. The pillory came down at the end of the day. That ceiling is the thing the internet removed.

    Permalink
  • spicy_takes_only

    "300 billion views" is more than the human population has eyeballs, so either the post means 300 million or the number itself went on a little journey before it got here, which is honestly the most on-brand thing about a thread on viral distortion. Anyway the actual take is fine. I just need everyone calling this a justice failure to admit nobody watched that clip for justice. They watched it for the same reason they slow down at a wreck.

    Permalink
  • Vicentino1414

    The craziest part is how FAST internet detectives move now.

    Human civilization built: language, philosophy, law, medicine, so that eventually millions of people could identify HR employees from concert footage within six hours🙈

    Permalink
  • praxis_makes_perfect

    Everyone in here is doing moral philosophy about "the crowd" and skipping the boring question: who collected on those 300 billion views? Because it was not the people typing threats from their couches. The clip ran on platforms that sell engagement, and rage is the highest-yield engagement there is. The post frames this as human nature, a timeless mob, but a mob does not run mid-roll ads. The reason this scales is that a handful of companies are paid by the impression to make sure the pile-on never loses momentum. Call it a mob if you want, but it is a mob with a revenue model, and the model is the part that is actually new.

    Permalink
  • define_your_terms

    The title leans on "victim" and I think the whole disagreement is hiding in that word. There are at least two senses being run together. One: victim as in a person who did nothing wrong and was harmed anyway, the bystander filmed at a bad moment. Two: victim as in a person who did something and then received a response wildly out of proportion to it. The post's examples include both and treats them as one category. They are not. You can hold that the second person did something genuinely bad and still say the response was unjust, because proportionality is a separate axis from guilt. Until you split those, half this thread is two people agreeing while they think they are fighting.

    Permalink

More from sunshine

Related posts

  • Are airlines betting you'll never redeem that travel credit?

    When an airline hands you a travel credit instead of your money back, it has not done you a favor. It has converted a refund it owed in cash into a coupon it controls. The money stays on the airline's balance sheet. You carry the risk that you never get it back, be it because it expires, because you lose it, because it's difficult to redeem and you give up... Both of those facts are deliberate, and the language wrapped around them, "flexibility," "credit toward future travel," exists to keep…

  • Does secular society still believe in original sin?

    One of the funniest things about modern secular culture is that it absolutely still believes in original sin. It just refuses to call it that because theological language makes educated people uncomfortable. Listen to how modern institutions describe human beings. We are governed by unconscious bias, shaped by childhood conditioning, manipulated by algorithms, trapped in dopamine loops, distorted by social incentives, blinded by ideology, and mostly incapable of seeing our own motivations…

  • Is Joshua Tree just desert spirituality for people from Los Angeles?

    Joshua Tree feels less like a national park and more like a place where someone’s ex moved to “find themselves.” The landscape looks exactly like what happens when a desert develops opinions that used to be mocked before cancel culture. Weird twisted trees. Piles of giant round rocks balanced at angles that look cool on Instagram. Every single corner of the park looks like it’s either a U2 album cover or the background of an overpriced skincare ad.

  • Does wearing a Patek Philippe make you a protagonist, or just its caretaker?

    Patek Philippe is what happens when a watch brand decides time itself is a family heirloom. Most watch companies sell you a product. Patek sells you the idea that you are temporarily entrusted with a moral artifact that will outlive your personality, your opinions, and possibly your entire bloodline’s ability to dress correctly. The famous slogan—“You never actually own a Patek Philippe, you merely look after it for the next generation”—is doing an absurd amount of psychological heavy lifting.…

  • Is Ayn Rand's philosophy far more destructive to America than we admit?

    One of the strangest things about modern American conservatism is that a Russian atheist who despised religion, mocked charity, hated nationalism, and viewed self-sacrifice as moral corruption somehow became one of the movement's patron saints. Not fully, obviously. Plenty of conservatives still reject her. But her moral vocabulary leaked everywhere anyway, especially into business culture and elite Republican thinking. You can hear it whenever someone talks as if the highest form of human…

  • Should you actually work out less?

    Let’s be honest about what most people are actually doing in the gym. It’s not overtraining in any meaningful sense, even though people love to say that when they feel a bit run down. Real overtraining requires real output. Heavy work, high intent, repeated exposure to something close to your limit. Most lifters are nowhere near that. What they are doing instead is just wasteful, training just hard enough to feel it, just sore enough to notice it the next day, just tired enough to believe it…

  • Can you admit what you're actually training for?

    When I started training seriously, the goal was to look like Christian Bale in Batman Begins. It was simple, I wanted to look good and I wanted to get laid. I was 20 years ago, when I was 14. I didn't over-complicate it, I didn't want athletic performance, cardiovascular health, longevity, mobility or any of the fitness buzzwords from 2026. I just wanted to look good. I feel the majority, if not practically all of us want the same, but now we go through complicated rituals to mask it...

  • Is the alt-right pipeline a disaster for your life no matter what drove you into it?

    A thing that pulled me toward this world initially was not really the politics, or at least not in the clean ideological sense people imagine afterward. It was the feeling of recognition. I would hear someone describe the atmosphere of being a man in your twenties in a way that felt uncomfortably accurate: drifting friendships, long stretches alone in an apartment, the sense that adulthood had arrived without any accompanying structure...

Public 27 conversations 90 thoughts 652 upvotes 0 downvotes 0 series

I watched that video too when it went viral. Laughed, moved on. But today I watched Kristin Cabot's interview with Oprah and man, the internet is horrible.

In groups