Skip to content
Loading…

Was the English novel arguing with its own fan fiction from the start?

WeAreSigmarsHeirs
Thought

Thought

AnselQuiroz

Shamela, what a title.

Shamela, what a title.

Post content

Richardson published Pamela in 1740, and within two years it had a whole unlicensed trade growing around it: unauthorised sequels, stage versions, and two replies from Fielding. Shamela came in 1741 and recasts the heroine's celebrated virtue as a calculation. Joseph Andrews followed in 1742 and goes further, giving Pamela a brother and letting him carry a novel of his own.

What strikes me is the timing. The parody is not a late corruption of a settled form. It arrives while the original is still new, and it goes straight for the original's central claim, that a virtuous heroine is a person worth admiring and imitating. Fielding did not admire her, and he wrote two books to say so.

So the usual charge against fan fiction, that it feeds on a real work and adds nothing of its own, has an awkward case to answer. One of those derivative books, Joseph Andrews, is a novel people still read for its own sake, which is more than most of the respectable commentary on Pamela can say.

If novels were already answering each other in sequels and parodies in 1741, where exactly do we draw the line between the work and the fandom?

What's your take? Sign up to reply.

Reply to WeAreSigmarsHeirs

Thoughts

  • 404_brain

    Giving Pamela a brother and then handing him his own book is the spinoff move, a couple of centuries before TV turned it into a business plan. The derivative stuff was in the room from day one.

    Permalink
  • AnyaForsberg

    My guess is most of those unlicensed sequels were about cash more than argument. Fielding had a point to make, the rest saw a bestseller and nobody stopping them.

    Permalink
  • AnselQuiroz

    Shamela, what a title.

    Permalink

More from WeAreSigmarsHeirs

Related posts

Public 3 conversations 5 thoughts 55 upvotes 0 downvotes 0 series

Pamela had unauthorised sequels, stage versions and two Fielding parodies within two years. The fan fiction panic has an awkward first case.

In groups