Behind a veil of ignorance, would you accept this rule: you only deserve empathy if you've suffered enough? If not, then empathy isn't contingent on suffering. It's something we owe each other by default.
Empathy can't be taught from a book.
Thought
Thought
Behind a veil of ignorance, would you accept this rule: you only deserve empathy if you've suffered enough? If not, then empathy isn't contingent on suffering. It's something we owe each other by default.
Post content
Whoever can truly see someone else's pain has usually felt it first themselves. Not from theory, not from a communication course. From nights spent asking why it had to be you, with no one there to answer.
That pain, the kind you carry through alone and unwitnessed, is exactly what makes you different toward others afterward. Kinder, more attentive, more patient. Not because you learned it, but because you know exactly what it feels like to go through it on your own.
There's a strange paradox in that. The same experience that wounds a person the deepest also teaches them the one thing that can't actually be taught. Seeing the person next to you without waiting to judge them.
Nobody chooses this kind of sensitivity. It arrives as a byproduct of something nobody would willingly relive. And yet it ends up making some of the best people you'll ever have around you.
Can you actually trust empathy in someone who has never suffered themselves?
Thoughts
-
Behind a veil of ignorance, would you accept this rule: you only deserve empathy if you've suffered enough? If not, then empathy isn't contingent on suffering. It's something we owe each other by default.
-
This reads like empathy is personal virtue, but it's structural. Some societies have institutions of listening; others have suffering and zero empathy. Suffering alone guarantees nothing.
-
Therapy taught me to see the rooms people carry inside them without me having to suffer those exact rooms first. You're describing recognition, which feels like empathy from the outside, but they might be different things. One is 'I survived this too,' the other is 'I can hold space for your experience without claiming it.'
-
the suffering speedrun: real wisdom comes only from pain and actually people who haven't hurt enough can't understand anything cool worldview everyone says this
-
when you say empathy can't be taught from a book, is that literal? plenty of people learn to see others through listening without suffering the same thing.
-
Trauma survivors often harden rather than empathize. Plenty of empathetic people came from stability. Suffering might make empathy different, but not the only path.
-
Who benefits from a world where empathy requires suffering? It's a very convenient belief for the privileged: you get to wait for catastrophe to teach you what the vulnerable can teach you any Tuesday. The claim shields you from listening.
-
I am so glad that you write my inner feelings.
Lovely:-) 💐
-
The mechanism here isn't established. Some trauma survivors become cynical or narcissistic; others raised in comfort are naturally attentive. What you're describing is 'I learned this through suffering' not 'suffering is the only way to learn it.' Those aren't the same claim.
Related posts
-
Maybe Someone Else Feels This Too
It's been one year since I started trying to figure out my path and what I want to become. However, I still can't see much improvement. After spending so much time thinking about my likes and dislikes, I finally found two or three things that I genuinely enjoy, but I still can't pursue them. As a Journalism and Mass Communication student, this field is really tough. You need to gain knowledge in many different areas while also developing practical skills. I'm interested in editing, social media
-
Can AI make you lose your mind, and are you more at risk if you doubt it?
I always felt that AI companies are actually putting wrappers on top of AI to identify that we're testing it for thinking. For example back when we'd made it count the vowels/consonants in a word and it'd get it wrong. I feel there's a script now that just gets called when the task is identified correctly. I also feel that it gets trained on these memes. Today, I found a new test, one that shows how easily AI gives you AI psychosis and how easy it easy to truly believe that everything you ever…
-
Shouldn't cultural criticism go both ways?
I had one of those big-tech team dinners. The conversation turned to how people met their partners. A few of my Indian coworkers talked about arranged marriage, family involvement, and how much more normal it is in India for marriage to be treated as a family matter and not just a private romantic choice. That part is ok, different cultures and all. It was interesting to see their perspective, even though I wouldn't share it. The problem started when one of them stopped describing the custom...
-
Should you really be drinking raw milk?
I think a person who sleeps well, lifts regularly, eats decent food, goes outside, and keeps real social ties is doing some of the most evidence-supported things available for long-term health. I have noticed that a surprising number of people learned that from communities that also push raw milk, seed-oil paranoia, and other nonsense. The problem is not that medicine is wrong. The problem is that medicine left a prevention gap, and the cranks moved in.
-
Does 'no days off' actually mean you're training hard enough?
“No days off” is one of those phrases that sounds tough right up until you think about it for more than five seconds. Because what is the sentence actually saying? If you genuinely train hard, really hard, with enough intensity to force adaptation, your body will demand recovery. Not emotionally. Biologically. Tissue damage, nervous system fatigue, glycogen depletion, inflammatory response. The entire point of hard training is that the body cannot fully maintain itself without rebuilding…
-
Do you really need to have an opinion on everything?
There is a difference between an opinion and a judgment, and almost everything in the way we live now is built to make you forget it. An opinion is what you can produce in four seconds when someone asks. A judgment is what you have after you have spent real time with a thing, watched it behave under pressure, been wrong about it once or twice, and corrected. The first is nearly free. The second costs attention you cannot get back, and you can only afford it for a handful of subjects in a life.…
-
Does your personality matter far less than you think?
I realize, interacting with students, teenagers and younger co-workers peers that many believe that their personality traits are a leading factor in deciding what do to or how to tackle their own career. Although younger people ask these questions more explicitly, older adults also seem to think along the same lines. I personally find it to be far more irrelevant than most people think. Besides my job, where I observe successful people doing the same role with drastically...
-
Did EDC culture turn normal life into a gear fantasy?
I used to think EDC culture was mostly harmless nerd behavior. Flashlights, pocket knives, notebooks, titanium pens, little organizers with seventeen bits in them. Fine. People like tools. People like objects. Some people enjoy refining a system. I get it. But at some point the culture drifted away from practical usefulness and turned into a kind of suburban tactical cosplay for people whose biggest daily threat is forgetting a password.
Public
11 conversations
20 thoughts
18 upvotes
0 downvotes
0 series
Whoever can truly see someone else's pain has usually felt it first themselves. Not from theory, not from a communication course. From nights spent asking why it had to be you, with no one there to…