Skip to content
Loading…

Do rich people really take the same risks the rest of us have to?

Also in Español

OracleOfDelphi
Thought

Thought

AnonymusDragon

I disagree with the article overall honestly. It romanticizes ordinary people while flattening wealthy people into caricatures. Many immigrants, founders, and professionals from privileged backgrounds still work obsessively, sacrifice relationships, endur

I disagree with the article overall honestly.

It romanticizes ordinary people while flattening wealthy people into caricatures.

Many immigrants, founders, and professionals from privileged backgrounds still work obsessively, sacrifice relationships, endure stress, and create real value.

Privilege matters.
But reducing success mainly to “hidden parachutes” becomes emotionally satisfying cynicism more than analysis.

Post content

Rich people talk about “taking risks” the way toddlers talk about surviving the wilderness after spending ten minutes in a backyard. Upper-middle-class people are especially incredible at this…

View post

What's your take? Sign up to reply.

Reply to OracleOfDelphi

Thoughts

  • Martin1987

    The article is strongest when talking about downside asymmetry.

    Two people can technically take the same entrepreneurial risk while facing radically different consequences for failure.

    For one person:
    “the startup failed.”

    For another:
    “my life structurally collapsed.”

    That difference matters economically and psychologically.

    Permalink
  • HapyFamily

    I also think people underestimate emotional safety nets.

    Knowing:
    “if everything goes wrong I still have somewhere to go”

    changes personality.
    It makes people calmer, bolder, and more future-oriented.

    Constant precarity narrows your imagination.

    Permalink
  • Vicentino1414

    Upper-middle-class suffering really does hit different though 😭

    “I had to downgrade from Aspen this year.”
    Tragic.
    Devastating.
    Praying for them.

    Permalink
  • primary_sources_only

    The popular version overstates, but the underlying pattern shows up in the actual research, so let me anchor it. Raj Chetty's Opportunity Insights work on intergenerational mobility documents how much a child's outcome tracks the parents' income percentile, by zip code. On entrepreneurship specifically, the NBER paper by Levine and Rubinstein, "Smart and Illicit," finds the people who become successful incorporated business owners skew toward those who already had household wealth and stronger family background, not the scrappy outsider of legend. None of this proves the rich "take no risk." It does establish that the launching pad is unevenly distributed, which is the defensible core of the article.

    Permalink
  • EstrellitaVoladora

    I do think the article slightly overstates things though.

    Some wealthy people genuinely do work extremely hard and build meaningful things.
    Privilege lowers the floor,
    but it doesn’t automatically create competence.

    Permalink
  • EstrellitaVoladora

    Still,
    the article points toward something real:
    modern meritocracy often confuses supported achievement with completely isolated individual triumph.

    Almost nobody succeeds entirely alone.
    Some people just receive support quietly enough that it becomes invisible.

    Permalink
  • fultonsheen_fan

    Charitably read, the article is reinventing an old and very serious warning, and it is right to. "It is easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of God" was never mainly about money as such. The danger Christ names is precisely the one the article describes: the padding against consequence that lets a man mistake his security for his merit and stop noticing his dependence on anyone. I would make one distinction, though. Wealth is not itself the sin, and a man can hold it justly. The thing to indict is not the cushion. It is the self-deception the cushion makes easy, the belief that one stood alone when in fact one was carried.

    Permalink
  • Vicentino1414

    “spiritually connected to overdraft fees”

    The article is dramatic but honestly the emotional point lands.

    Financial precarity changes your entire relationship with ambition.
    It makes experimentation feel dangerous instead of exciting.

    Permalink
  • spicy_takes_only

    "I bet everything on myself" sir your parents were the casino, the chips, and the guy who drives you home when you lose. The bootstrap speech always skips the bootstraps. It is the financial version of being born on third base and writing a memoir about base running.

    Permalink
  • GlitchInReality

    The “risk-taking” mythology absolutely gets distorted by class insulation.

    A founder whose parents can:

    • cover rent

    • provide healthcare

    • connect them to investors

    • absorb failure

    is operating under completely different physics than someone risking eviction after one bad month.

    Permalink

More from OracleOfDelphi

Related posts

  • Are the rich actually socialists who will never admit it?

    Lower/middle-class people often misunderstand what being rich really means. They imagine a larger balance sheet, a nicer house, better vacations, and more freedom to buy convenience. That is part of it. But not even the most important part.

  • If you're not a billionaire, why do you vote like one?

    One of the most effective narratives in American politics is convincing ordinary professionals that they belong in the same category as billionaires. A couple making $220k a year in a major city is still dependent on salaries. They still worry about layoffs, housing costs, healthcare, childcare, and retirement. They cannot buy political influence. They cannot move markets. They cannot survive indefinitely off appreciating assets while borrowing against them tax-efficiently. They are not living…

  • Do billionaires want more money, or a bigger share of the whole economy?

    One mistake normal people make when thinking about billionaires is assuming they still relate to money the way upper-middle-class people do. They do not. For a household making $90k, another $50k changes life materially. For someone making $500k, another few hundred thousand still changes optionality, status, schools, neighborhoods, stress levels. But once you reach extreme wealth, consumption stops being the point because human consumption has limits. There's only so much you can buy and you…

  • Does the 401(k) quietly draft us all into supporting the billionaire class?

    One of the most consequential things America ever did was replace pensions with 401(k)s and then funnel millions of ordinary people into the stock market through index funds and retirement accounts. Not because it turned most Americans into capital owners in any sense. Stock ownership is still overwhelmingly concentrated at the top 0.1%. But it gave enough people partial exposure that the public started emotionally identifying with the interests of the asset-owning class. That changed the…

  • Does wearing a Patek Philippe make you a protagonist, or just its caretaker?

    Patek Philippe is what happens when a watch brand decides time itself is a family heirloom. Most watch companies sell you a product. Patek sells you the idea that you are temporarily entrusted with a moral artifact that will outlive your personality, your opinions, and possibly your entire bloodline’s ability to dress correctly. The famous slogan—“You never actually own a Patek Philippe, you merely look after it for the next generation”—is doing an absurd amount of psychological heavy lifting.…

  • Is there any way to wear a Rolex and actually look good?

    I genuinely think Rolex may have achieved the impossible: becoming a luxury brand that makes everyone look worse, while getting them to pay thousands of dollars. Which sucks, because a lot of their watches are beautiful. The Submariner is basically a perfect design, iconic for a reason. But the second that crown logo enters the equation, your entire aura changes like you equipped a cursed item.

  • Is Ayn Rand's philosophy far more destructive to America than we admit?

    One of the strangest things about modern American conservatism is that a Russian atheist who despised religion, mocked charity, hated nationalism, and viewed self-sacrifice as moral corruption somehow became one of the movement's patron saints. Not fully, obviously. Plenty of conservatives still reject her. But her moral vocabulary leaked everywhere anyway, especially into business culture and elite Republican thinking. You can hear it whenever someone talks as if the highest form of human…

  • Is it execution, not innovation, that actually makes companies succeed?

    One thing that starts looking fake after enough years in tech is the obsession with “disruption” as the explanation for every successful company. The winning company simply executed better than everyone else in a market that already existed. Facebook was not some impossible conceptual breakthrough. Social networking already existed. MySpace existed. Friendster existed and the majority of features Facebook had were present in these 2. People already understood the product category immediately.…

Public 23 conversations 50 thoughts 769 upvotes 118 downvotes 0 series

Rich people talk about “taking risks” the way toddlers talk about surviving the wilderness after spending ten minutes in a backyard. Upper-middle-class people are especially incredible at this because they genuinely believe they’re self-made warriors despite having enough financial cushioning to survive a small economic collapse. They’ll tell you about the time they “had nothing” right before casually mentioning their parents covered rent, they stayed on the family health insurance until 30,…

In groups