Skip to content
Loading…

How could you.

Bebel
Thought

Thought

fultonsheen_fan

Forgiving someone and hoping they never forget sit together better than people expect. The old moral writers kept the two apart on purpose: forgiveness is what you let go of, remembering is what you keep. The last stanzas do both, and I'd defend that as t

Forgiving someone and hoping they never forget sit together better than people expect. The old moral writers kept the two apart on purpose: forgiveness is what you let go of, remembering is what you keep. The last stanzas do both, and I'd defend that as the sane place to end up.

Post content

How could you do that to a soul

that only wanted good for you?

How could you do that to a soul

that loved you more than itself?

Why would you do that

to someone who gave you everything—

everything they had,

everything they were,

everything they could be?

They loved you so much

they would have put themselves on fire just to keep you warm.

And you used that.

You watched them burn,

and still, you asked for more.

They had their own troubles,

keeping them from sleeping at night,

but they pushed them aside,

silenced their screams,

just so they could listen to yours.

They believed in you.

God, they trusted you.

And you made them wish they hadn’t.

Who are they supposed to believe in now?

You’re a #####.

I don’t know if you didn’t notice,

or if you just didn’t care.

If you ignored the way their eyes

shone with devotion,

or if you simply liked the way

that light dimmed

every time you hurt them a little more.

They killed themselves

to keep the ‘us’ alive—

but you never wanted it.

You never wanted them.

Not the way they wanted you.

And now?

Now, they’ll never forgive themselves

for always forgiving you.

For letting you in again and again,

knowing you’d do the same thing

every single round.

They tried so hard

to be what you needed,

to mold themselves into

whatever the hell you wanted,

but in the end,

you never needed anything, did you?

But they don’t hate you,

they never could.

Because their soul is pure,

because they were made to love,

because they see the best in people

even when they shouldn’t.

They forgive you.

But I hope you never forget.

I hope their love haunts you,

follows you like a shadow,

claws at the back of your mind

every time you try to sleep.

I hope you remember.

They loved you like Van Gogh loved art,

and you loved them

like Van Gogh loved life.

What's your take? Sign up to reply.

Reply to Bebel

Thoughts

  • Ovid

    The eyes shining with devotion, and that light going down a little more every time, is what I kept thinking about after the angry parts. It makes me think of how slowly this kind of thing happens, nobody sees the day it goes out. I bet the person it's about would recognise themselves in that stanza before anywhere else.

    Permalink
  • gwen64

    Forgiving them over and over, and then being the one who can't forgive yourself for it, is what I keep turning over. I've watched a friend do exactly that for years with a man who never once changed, and she still talks about him kindly. I bet whoever this is about would hear it and think it was about somebody else.

    Permalink
  • benfromnights

    Putting yourself on fire to keep someone warm is the bit I still had in my head an hour after.

    Permalink
  • readsOnTheTrain

    The fire to keep someone warm, and then the watching them burn. That order is the whole thing for me.

    Permalink
  • fultonsheen_fan

    Forgiving someone and hoping they never forget sit together better than people expect. The old moral writers kept the two apart on purpose: forgiveness is what you let go of, remembering is what you keep. The last stanzas do both, and I'd defend that as the sane place to end up.

    Permalink
  • MelanieOdum

    I have been in a lot of kitchens with people talking about someone exactly like this. They forgive him in one breath and hope he never forgets in the next, and both are true at once. This keeps both instead of picking one, which is the version people actually live. I'd put money on the person it's for never seeing it, and on that being fine.

    Permalink
  • NikhilRaman

    The ending turns into a curse, the kind from old tales: the love follows them like a shadow and claws at them every night. My guess is that stanza came first and the rest was built back toward it.

    Permalink
  • samReads2

    Van Gogh loving art, then Van Gogh loving life, as the last flip is kind of a mean little twist, and I love that it shows up right after all the forgiving.

    Permalink
  • theointhebackrow

    Oof. Whole thing hurts

    Permalink
  • PaulaOkonkwo

    Molding yourself into whatever the other person wants is the slow kind of disappearing, and nobody around you notices until there's not much left. My sister spent a whole marriage doing that.

    Permalink

More from Bebel

  • Intolerância

    Eu não entendo esse assunto controverso que é religião,

  • "Verde"

    O poema de hoje vai ser sobre a cor verde .

Related posts

  • Does your personality matter far less than you think?

    I realize, interacting with students, teenagers and younger co-workers peers that many believe that their personality traits are a leading factor in deciding what do to or how to tackle their own career. Although younger people ask these questions more explicitly, older adults also seem to think along the same lines. I personally find it to be far more irrelevant than most people think. Besides my job, where I observe successful people doing the same role with drastically...

  • Make it Make Sense

    Backward and forward, tow, but cause to hoe is forward and backward. Enough has been said but there is too much to hold. Count feathers too light but the wind is heavy, but it is too much to ask,…

  • Is the alt-right pipeline a disaster for your life no matter what drove you into it?

    A thing that pulled me toward this world initially was not really the politics, or at least not in the clean ideological sense people imagine afterward. It was the feeling of recognition. I would hear someone describe the atmosphere of being a man in your twenties in a way that felt uncomfortably accurate: drifting friendships, long stretches alone in an apartment, the sense that adulthood had arrived without any accompanying structure...

  • Shouldn't cultural criticism go both ways?

    I had one of those big-tech team dinners. The conversation turned to how people met their partners. A few of my Indian coworkers talked about arranged marriage, family involvement, and how much more normal it is in India for marriage to be treated as a family matter and not just a private romantic choice. That part is ok, different cultures and all. It was interesting to see their perspective, even though I wouldn't share it. The problem started when one of them stopped describing the custom...

  • Did EDC culture turn normal life into a gear fantasy?

    I used to think EDC culture was mostly harmless nerd behavior. Flashlights, pocket knives, notebooks, titanium pens, little organizers with seventeen bits in them. Fine. People like tools. People like objects. Some people enjoy refining a system. I get it. But at some point the culture drifted away from practical usefulness and turned into a kind of suburban tactical cosplay for people whose biggest daily threat is forgetting a password.

  • Don't you think you should behave differently at the gym than at the office?

    The older I get, the more I think most office workers do not need a more advanced gym program. They need to stop behaving like office workers for one hour. I am an office worker, but I feel I'm smarter about it. Let's go for big brain time Look, you sit all day at work. Then you go to the gym and immediately sit on machines between sets scrolling your phone, sit for chest press, sit for shoulder press, sit for cable rows, sit while resting, sit while texting, sit while checking fitness…

  • Does 'no days off' actually mean you're training hard enough?

    “No days off” is one of those phrases that sounds tough right up until you think about it for more than five seconds. Because what is the sentence actually saying? If you genuinely train hard, really hard, with enough intensity to force adaptation, your body will demand recovery. Not emotionally. Biologically. Tissue damage, nervous system fatigue, glycogen depletion, inflammatory response. The entire point of hard training is that the body cannot fully maintain itself without rebuilding…

  • Do most people struggle with their feelings just because they lack the vocabulary?

    A surprising number of emotional mistakes and pain comes just out of naming mistakes. Someone says he is angry when he is really ashamed. Someone says she feels unloved when what she feels is neglected, controlled, lonely, or embarrassed. Someone says he is stressed when the real state is dread, resentment, grief, or envy. Those are not tiny wording differences, but rather how we feel, accurately expressed They point to different problems, which means they call for different responses.

Public 10 conversations 12 thoughts 31 upvotes 0 downvotes 1 series

How could you do that to a soul

In series

In groups