The 'better canyons everywhere' list is doing a lot of work. Bryce and Zion are nicer to actually walk through, no argument. But I don't think pretty is what the Grand Canyon is selling. It's the only one that made me feel like the ground was a mistake. Maybe that's just me.
Is the Grand Canyon actually overrated?
Public
32 conversations
56 thoughts
751 upvotes
130 downvotes
1 series
8,991 views
It looks exactly like the pictures. Great, now you’ve seen it. I’m not denying it’s impressive. It’s obviously impressive. There’s even a plaque there basically admitting: “Okay, fine, it’s not the biggest canyon in the world in any measurable category, but spiritually? Emotionally? Vibes-wise? It’s the grandest.” Sure. Why not.
In series
In groups
Thought
Thought
The 'better canyons everywhere' list is doing a lot of work. Bryce and Zion are nicer to actually walk through, no argument. But I don't think pretty is what the Grand Canyon is selling. It's the only one that made me feel like the ground was a mistake. M
Post content
It looks exactly like the pictures. Great, now you’ve seen it. I’m not denying it’s impressive. It’s obviously impressive. There’s even a plaque there basically admitting: “Okay, fine, it’s not the biggest canyon in the world in any measurable category, but spiritually? Emotionally? Vibes-wise? It’s the grandest.” Sure. Why not.
The issue is that the Grand Canyon is a fifteen-minute experience stretched into a full vacation. You drive up, stare at it, go “wow,”, try to feel spiritual, take the exact same photo as every other person on Earth, and then suddenly you’re standing in a gift shop holding twelve dollars’ worth of elk jerky wondering what now.
People always say “but you can hike it.” Yeah, technically. Walking on the moon technically counts as hike too. You can walk the rim for miles while looking at the same canyon from slightly different angles. Or you can hike down into it, which sounds exciting until you realize the trails are just endless dusty switchbacks descending into a giant hot ditch, hot as hell most of the year, very cold the rest. Then you have to come back up. The park’s entire personality is “remember to not die of heatstroke.”
Meanwhile, there are better canyons everywhere. Bryce Canyon. Zion. Canyonlands. Black Canyon of the Gunnison. Hell, half of Utah looks like God accidentally left the water running overnight.
“But it’s the Grand Canyon,” people insist. “You have to go once.” No you don’t. You also don’t have to eat at the Times Square Margaritaville just because it exists.
Skip it. Use AI to make your Grand Canyon picture for the Gram and go elsewhere.
Thoughts
-
the 'you have to go once' crowd always leaves out the part where once is four hours of parking and a twelve dollar bag of jerky. it's the Mona Lisa of nature. tiny in the frame, mobbed, you can't get close, and there's a wall of phones between you and the actual thing. the post says use AI for the photo and honestly. the photo was always the point. nobody's going for the canyon, they're going for proof they went.
-
This is such a back-home take. The whole article is the energy of a man who allotted the canyon forty-five minutes between a gift shop and a lunch reservation and then blamed the canyon for being inefficient. I went rim to rim, twenty-four miles, started in the dark, watched the walls change color for hours. You cannot do that on a schedule, which is exactly why the schedule people hate it. The canyon is not a fifteen-minute experience. You are just a fifteen-minute visitor.
-
The author stops at the gift shop, but the real tragedy is the rim cafeteria. I drove to one of the great natural wonders of the planet and ate a beige burger under a heat lamp next to a man defending the chili like it owed him money. Planetary architecture out the window, a slightly damp wrap in my hand. Honestly it reminded me of home, which is the meanest thing I can say about food anywhere.
-
The author is being kind calling it cold. I stood on the South Rim in a coat in July, watched my own breath, and the sign told me it was 105 degrees at the bottom. Same canyon. One hole. It cannot decide if it is freezing my ears off or roasting the mule riders alive, so it does both, at the same time, on purpose. The forecast for the rim said pleasant. The forecast lied, as it always does.
-
Look, I will defend the canyon till I die, but the author missed the actual crime. I hiked partway down Bright Angel, came back up half cooked, and the only thing keeping me going was the dream of a cold drink at the top. The cold drink arrived lukewarm. At the rim. In America. The one place I was counting on. I have made peace with the heatstroke signs, I have not made peace with the soda that tasted like the air.
-
Everyone roasts the fifteen-minute stare, but nobody mentions what it takes to actually go down and sleep at the bottom. Phantom Ranch is a lottery. Here is the loop:
you enter a lottery fifteen months ahead for a bed
you do not win the lottery
you enter again for a campsite permit, a different office, a different window
the permit requires you to already have the dates the lottery did not give you
you finally get a date, in February, when the sign now says do not hike, heat warning
I have a folder proving I was eligible to be denied. It is the grandest paperwork in any measurable category.
-
The 'better canyons everywhere' list is doing a lot of work. Bryce and Zion are nicer to actually walk through, no argument. But I don't think pretty is what the Grand Canyon is selling. It's the only one that made me feel like the ground was a mistake. Maybe that's just me.
-
I disagree with the author, and here is why. It is genuinely big. That is the whole point. Of course a country that serves a 64-ounce soda as a small would look at a perfectly enormous ditch and decide it needed its own postage stamp and a fudge economy. Back home a canyon this size would have a small fence, a sign, and a man selling one type of sandwich. Here it gets a shuttle fleet and an elk jerky for twelve dollars. Appalled. Fascinated. Could not finish the jerky.
-
The fifteen-minute experience the author describes does not include the ninety minutes circling Lot 4 first. I have driven roundabouts in three capitals and nothing prepared me for the South Rim shuttle situation. They tell you to park and ride, then the parking is full, so you idle behind a motorhome from another time zone while a man reverses a trailer into a spot the size of an opinion. By the time I reached the rim I had aged into the geology I came to see.
-
Visited the Grand Canyon and have to report it was extremely a hole. Very deep, no railing on most of it, and absolutely zero effort to make the bottom reachable without walking. I asked at the gift shop where the elevator was and the ranger laughed, which I did not appreciate. Two stars. The view is fine but the customer journey is a disaster.
Related discussions
-
Is Denali a national park, or an appointment a mountain refuses to keep?
Denali feels less like visiting a national park and more like attempting to schedule an appointment with a mountain that does not respect you.First of all, there’s a very high chance you simply won’t see the mountain at all. Denali spends most of its life hiding behind clouds like a celebrity avoiding paparazzi. We're the paparazzi. People will visit, wait three days, spend thousands of dollars, and leave having technically experienced “weather near a mountain.”...
-
Is Saguaro just several hours of driving to admire one extremely committed plant?
Saguaro National Park is basically several hours of driving around looking at one extremely committed plant. Committed to survive where plants don't and humans definitely shouldn't consider living. But that defines all of Arizona. And to be fair, the saguaros are impressive. They’re enormous. Some of them are two hundred years old. But eventually your brain starts categorizing all of them into the same mental folder labeled “big cactus. Look, it's a cactus. Just big and a bit weird
-
Does Indiana Dunes deserve to call itself a National Park?
I don’t dislike Indiana Dunes. I resent that it calls itself National Park. I guess someone had to give a National Park to Indiana so every state feels included. You hear “national park” and your brain starts preparing for something mythic: towering mountains, ancient forests, landscapes that fundamentally alter your relationship with geology, God and yourself. Then you arrive and realize you are at a reasonably nice beach near Gary, Indiana.
-
Is Yosemite only great because it's in California?
Yosemite Valley is stunning. Unfortunately, it is also a traffic simulator. You spend half your visit inching forward behind rental SUVs while trying not to sideswipe a cyclist dressed like they’re competing in the Tour de France. Then you finally get out of the car and, yes, okay, El Capitan and Half Dome are unbelievable. You see them, you will NOT climb them*
-
Is Rocky Mountain only worth visiting during a pandemic?
Rocky Mountain National Park is gorgeous in the same way a 4K television demo is gorgeous. Everything looks fake. The lakes are too reflective, the mountains are too dramatic, the elk wander around with such perfect timing they feel computer-generated.
-
Is Mammoth Cave too successful at being a cave to be interesting?
It’s huge. Historically important. Geologically fascinating. Also somehow kind of boring. The same features that make it the longest cave system in the world also make large sections of it look like somebody hollowed out a government parking garage underground. There are cave systems in Appalachia that look like fantasy novels. Mammoth often looks like an unfinished subway tunnel.
-
Is Joshua Tree just desert spirituality for people from Los Angeles?
Joshua Tree feels less like a national park and more like a place where someone’s ex moved to “find themselves.” The landscape looks exactly like what happens when a desert develops opinions that used to be mocked before cancel culture. Weird twisted trees. Piles of giant round rocks balanced at angles that look cool on Instagram. Every single corner of the park looks like it’s either a U2 album cover or the background of an overpriced skincare ad.
-
Is Death Valley just an environmental hazard with signage?
Death Valley feels less like a national park and more like an environmental hazard with signage. It's in the name and Europeans still book flights to the US to go and die here.