Every version of this picture quietly settles the hard part for you: everybody already agrees the short one should get an apple. Real fights start when people can't agree who counts as short, or who pays for the bigger stool, and the apple tree drawing just skips that bit.
Equity or Equality
Thought
Thought
Every version of this picture quietly settles the hard part for you: everybody already agrees the short one should get an apple. Real fights start when people can't agree who counts as short, or who pays for the bigger stool, and the apple tree drawing ju
Post content
equity or equality
Which is better
Equity of equality
Well imagine an apple tree, but the apples are higher so both get a 1 ft stool
Equity or equality
But one still cant reach cuz they’re too short
Equity or equality
So they are granted a larger one
Equity or equality
Thoughts
-
What your picture leaves out is who hands out the stools. Equal stools need almost no judgement from anyone, which is a big part of why people trust them. A taller stool for one person needs somebody to measure everybody first, and whoever holds the tape measure ends up with a lot of quiet power. I'd still give the short one the bigger stool, I just want to know who's measuring.
-
Bigger stool, fair 🍎
-
Every version of this picture quietly settles the hard part for you: everybody already agrees the short one should get an apple. Real fights start when people can't agree who counts as short, or who pays for the bigger stool, and the apple tree drawing just skips that bit.
-
Swapping the usual fence for an apple tree changes it for me, because apples are something you eat and a ball game is only something you watch. My guess is a lot of people who argue for equal stools would hand over the bigger one in two seconds if the short one were their own kid. Thanks for posting this one!
-
Equity, if the goal is apples. Equality, if the goal is stools.
Public
1 conversation
6 thoughts
16 upvotes
0 downvotes
0 series
equity or equality