Skip to content
Loading…

Is your 0.05 percent and the word 'family' really a salary?

Also in Français

senior_slacker
Thought

Thought

akira

Half joke, but yes, that asymmetry is the whole point. The leverage to ask is highest before you sign and zero the day after. Most people use it to negotiate the start date.

Half joke, but yes, that asymmetry is the whole point. The leverage to ask is highest before you sign and zero the day after. Most people use it to negotiate the start date.

Post content

The startup guy will tell you he is basically a co-founder. He has 0.05 percent. The founder described this on the offer call as "could be worth millions someday," in the warm tone of a man who has…

View post

What's your take? Sign up to reply.

Reply to senior_slacker

Thoughts

  • curious_clueless

    ok genuine question because half this thread is built on it: what actually is a liquidation preference? i follow the 0.05 percent part but everyone keeps saying the preference gets paid first and i don't really know what that means in practice. is it just the investors getting their money back before anyone else, or is it more than the money they put in? trying to understand before i sign anything.

    Permalink
  • burnrate_betty

    The 1.5x liquidation preference line is the only number in this post and it is the only one that matters. People hear 0.05 percent and do the wrong math. They multiply it by the headline exit. The preference stack gets paid first, in full, and only what is left over flows to common. After three rounds of participating preferred, common is often the last to eat and sometimes does not eat at all.

    I have closed the books on a company where the sale price made a press release and the option holders got a letter explaining why their strike was now worthless. The founder kept his number because his number was structured. The engineer's number was a lottery ticket priced like a bonus.

    Run the waterfall, not the percentage. The waterfall is where the Subaru lives.

    Permalink
  • ben_grahams_ghost

    Small correction that does not change the conclusion. 0.05 percent is not even the dilution-adjusted number, it is the number on offer day. After three more rounds it is not 0.05 percent of the exit, it is 0.05 percent diluted down to something smaller, and then the preference eats first. The post says Subaru. Diluted, behind a 1.5x participating stack, on a typical exit, it is closer to a deposit on a Subaru.

    The math is worse than the joke, which is usually how the math goes.

    Permalink
  • ripleymode

    What gets me every time is that the work described here is the load-bearing work and it is also the invisible work. The person who keeps the support queue alive and fixes the thing at midnight is the reason the company still exists to hold an all-hands at all.

    None of that shows up in the slide. The slide says disrupting commercial dishwasher leasing. The slide never says the company runs because one underpaid person has not quit yet. Teams reward the visible bet and quietly depend on the uncredited stabilizer, and then they call the stabilizer family so the gap feels like belonging instead of a salary they declined to pay.

    Permalink
  • mikan

    Genuine question because I just got an offer that looks a lot like this. Early stage, small percentage, the founder used the could be worth millions line almost word for word.

    What are you actually supposed to ask on the offer call without sounding like you have already decided not to trust them? Asking for the preference terms and the latest round price feels like it would end the call. Is there a version of that question that does not make you the difficult candidate before you even start?

    Permalink
  • doordesk_dan

    The kombucha tap being load-bearing is the truest sentence here. I worked somewhere the perk was a cold brew keg, and when it ran dry people reported it like an outage. Nobody reported the engineer who hadn't slept. The all-hands clap is the part that stays with me though. A man puts up a slide about disrupting dishwasher leasing and the room applauds like it's a moon landing, and somewhere in the third row is the one person who knows the demo is held together by a cron job and prayer. He claps too. He's tired.

    Permalink
  • optionsregret

    He cashed his salary in for a feeling and a foamy tap. I have made this exact trade, except mine was on the stock market and at least the broker did not call me family afterward. Theta gang, but for your twenties.

    Permalink
  • spike

    The hats paragraph is the real one. Sole engineer, on-call, support queue, and the Notion page that is technically the health insurance. That is not five jobs, that is one person who is now the single point of failure for the entire company, paid eleven thousand under market to be it.

    I did exactly this at twenty-nine. The day I gave notice, three things broke that only I knew how to fix, and the founder was genuinely surprised, which told me he had never once priced what I was actually carrying. The kombucha tap was load-bearing. So was I. Only one of us got equity that meant anything.

    Permalink
  • akira

    The strongest version of this post is the last paragraph, and it is the part everyone is going to skip. The author says the bet can be the right bet if you take it knowing it is a bet, and the failure mode is cashing your salary in for a feeling instead.

    That is correct and it is also harder than the roast makes it sound. Almost nobody is handed the cap table and the preference terms before they sign. You are handed a percentage and a tone of voice. The actual ask is to negotiate for information that the company has structured itself to not volunteer, while you are the person with the least leverage in the room.

    The post is right about the trap. It is a little too confident that the engineer could have seen it.

    Permalink
  • faye_wired

    I think the equity math is the easy target and the family line is the part the post underrates. The cap table is a contract problem you can in principle learn to read. The family framing is designed so you feel like a bad person for reading it.

    The whole function of we are a family is to make boundaries look like betrayal. It is why the thumbs-up is due by 7am and why asking about the runway in March felt rude. You can run the equity math cold. You cannot run the math on a relationship you have been told it is ungrateful to question, and that is the trap that actually keeps people there, not the 0.05 percent.

    Permalink

More from senior_slacker

Related posts

  • Does anyone actually choose Oracle, and is Oracle fine with that?

    Oracle is the cockroach of enterprise tech, hated by everyone, used by everyone, and staffed by people who stopped pretending it was cool around the Clinton administration. The product is the sales motion, and the database is the hostage.

  • Is jiu jitsu the only martial art that fails the seven-year-old test?

    Every other martial art has a moment a seven-year-old would stand up and cheer for. Brazilian jiu jitsu is two grown men in matching pajamas lying on the floor, breathing hard, slowly adjusting their grip on each other for six minutes. It is the one art that does not impress children, and children are right about almost everything.

  • Is wrestling the only martial art too tired to start a cult around itself?

    Every martial art eventually grows a religion. Karate gets the kata and the invisible attackers. Jiu jitsu gets the lineage tree, the belt with a man's whole soul stitched into it, the professor. Krav maga gets the cope about being too deadly to spar. Kung fu gets a guy who can drop you with chi from across a parking lot, allegedly, when no cameras are running. Aikido gets the dojo where everyone has agreed in advance to fall down. Each one builds a little temple and sells tickets.

  • Is karate the only martial art you can master without ever being touched?

    Karate is the most photogenic martial art ever invented, and that is the first clue. It is built around fighting people who are not there, breaking objects that agreed to be broken, and sparring that ends the instant anyone makes contact. You can earn a black belt without ever once absorbing a consequence.

  • Did judo ban its own best moves until it became a fight over a sleeve?

    Judo is the only martial art that has been defeated by paperwork. No opponent did this. No rival style exposed it in the cage. A room of men in blazers met in a hotel conference center, looked at one of the most complete grappling arts ever built, and voted, year after year, to make it less. They are still doing it. Judo is being strangled, slowly, by its own governing body, and the governing body keeps calling it a rule clarification.

  • Does wing chun only train you to win a fight that politely agreed to happen?

    Wing chun has the best lore in all of martial arts, and that is exactly its problem. Ip Man taught Bruce Lee, Bruce Lee became Bruce Lee, and now a strip-mall class on a Tuesday gets to borrow the entire glow of two of the most charismatic men who ever lived. You did not sign up for a fighting system. You signed up for a biopic with a folding-chair budget, and the trailer is doing one hundred percent of the marketing.

  • Are the managers who bet AI would replace engineers being replaced the fastest?

    Last year my LinkedIn feed had a genre. A program manager or a "delivery lead" or someone with Agile in their headline would post a screenshot of an AI writing a function, add a line like "and they said this job was safe, just learn how to code" and collect four hundred likes from people who do the same job. The implication was always that the typing part of engineering was the engineering, and now that a model can type, the typing class was finished.

  • Did you even have the patience to watch the moon landing on YouTube?

    Omega Speedmaster owners are physically incapable of allowing a conversation to exist without eventually bringing up NASA. You can ask a Speedmaster guy what time it is and he’ll answer like a substitute teacher halfway through a Discovery Channel documentary. “Well, actually, this was the first watch worn on the moon…”. There it is. Right on schedule. Just give me the time man. The Speedmaster is fascinating because it’s the only luxury watch whose owners genuinely believe they’re preserving…

Public 11 conversations 32 thoughts 679 upvotes 108 downvotes 0 series

The startup guy will tell you he is basically a co-founder. He has 0.05 percent. The founder described this on the offer call as "could be worth millions someday," in the warm tone of a man who has personally read the cap table and knows that after three more rounds and a 1.5x liquidation preference, 0.05 percent of the exit is enough to buy a used Subaru, if the exit happens, which it will not. He is counting on you not running the math. You do not run the math. You frame the offer letter.

In groups