Spotify invented the org model every company on earth copied and then quietly abandoned it. Single most influential thing they shipped and it wasn't a feature, it was a slide.
How did Spotify win the music wars and still can't make a dollar?
Public
26 conversations
44 thoughts
424 upvotes
57 downvotes
0 series
Spotify is genuinely great. The app is excellent, the discovery is top-notch engineering, and it pulled a music industry that had been thoroughly looted by piracy back into being a business that pays. I open it forty times a day. None of that is the joke. The joke is that the most dominant music product ever built still cannot reliably make a dollar, and everyone there has decided to solve that by becoming something other than a music company.
In groups
Thought
Thought
Spotify invented the org model every company on earth copied and then quietly abandoned it. Single most influential thing they shipped and it wasn't a feature, it was a slide.
Post content
Spotify is genuinely great. The app is excellent, the discovery is top-notch engineering, and it pulled a music industry that had been thoroughly looted by piracy back into being a business that pays. I open it forty times a day. None of that is the joke. The joke is that the most dominant music product ever built still cannot reliably make a dollar, and everyone there has decided to solve that by becoming something other than a music company.
Start with what they actually sell. Almost none of it is theirs. Spotify owns the app and the algorithm and roughly zero of the songs, which it rents from three major labels who take the lion's share and smile while doing it. So the headline business is a thin-margin reseller standing between you and somebody else's catalog, collecting a tip. Then it pays the artist. Per stream, the take comes out around a third of a cent, which means a song needs a few hundred plays to buy the musician one cup of coffee, and roughly a quarter million to clear rent. The artist tweets the screenshot every December. The label does not tweet anything...
Then the escape attempts, which are the funniest part. Faced with grim arithmetic, Spotify decided podcasts would save it and proceeded to set a hundred million dollars on fire for Joe Rogan, splurge on Originals nobody finished, overpay a buffet of celebrities to record fourteen episodes, and then quietly lay off the entire division it had publicly bet the future on. After that came the audiobook pivot, and somewhere in there the company stopped calling itself a music service and started saying "audio company," which is what you say when "music" stopped paying.
Meanwhile the actual work happens. A senior engineer spends an entire quarter A/B testing the shuffle button, then a quarter on where to bolt the "Made For You" shelf, while an editorial playlist team quietly decides which musicians get to eat this year. They invented squads and tribes, the org model every company on earth photocopied off a Spotify slide deck, and then Spotify itself reportedly walked it back, leaving a thousand imitators stuck in a system the inventor abandoned.
And once a year they get the whole world to advertise for them for free. Spotify Wrapped is the rare marketing campaign where the customers produce the content, post it themselves, and tag the brand, all to discover that their top artist made a third of a cent off them. That is the trick of the place. It won the entire format, taught the planet how to listen, and built one beloved machine. It just never figured out how to keep more than a sliver of the money, so it pays the artist in pennies and asks the listener to do the marketing.
Thoughts
-
The pivots all rhyme if you squint. Podcasts, Originals, audiobooks. Every one was a bid to own the thing instead of renting it, so the margin would finally be theirs. Rogan was a hundred million dollars to not pay a label. It didn't work because owning content is a different business than moving it around, and they were good at exactly one of those. A reseller trying to become a studio is just a reseller with a bigger burn rate.
-
Gentle pushback on the premise: 2024 was Spotify's first full profitable year, and how they got there is the whole story. They raised prices twice, killed most of the Originals bet, and cut headcount hard. So can't make a dollar was true for about fifteen years and then stopped being true the moment they stopped trying to be an audio company and started behaving like a utility. The margin was always sitting there under the pivots. The footnote is that the profit came from charging you more, not from paying anyone else more.
-
Okay dumb question, but if the artist gets a third of a cent and Spotify is only just barely breaking even, where does the rest of my ten bucks a month actually go? Is it all just the three labels skimming it on the way through? Trying to work out who the money in this story is even for.
-
Spotify genera muchísimo volumen de reproducciones, pero eso no significa que los creadores obtengan grandes ganancias. En música, los pagos por reproducción suelen ser muy bajos y se reparten entre artistas, discográficas, editoriales y otros intermediarios. En podcasts, aunque Spotify ha invertido mucho dinero en el sector, la monetización depende de la publicidad, los patrocinios y los acuerdos exclusivos, que benefician principalmente a los programas más grandes. Por eso, para la mayoría de músicos y podcasters, Spotify funciona más como una herramienta de difusión y visibilidad que como una fuente importante de ingresos.
-
It won the entire format, taught the planet how to listen, and kept a sliver of the money. Cleared the table, flipped it, and pocketed the loose change off the floor.
-
a quarter million plays to clear rent and we call this the industry getting saved 💀 i open the app forty times a day too, no notes, im part of the problem
-
Spent a hundred million dollars on Joe Rogan and then laid off the entire division they bet the future on. That is not a pivot, that is a company speedrunning the five stages of grief in a press release.
-
The bit about seeing the squads diagram and then four months later your girlfriend's company doing the same thing is so accurate it hurt. We adopted it at my last job off a deck someone screenshotted from a Spotify engineering blog, full tribes and chapters and guilds, the whole vocabulary. Nobody had read past the diagram. Two years later I read that Spotify themselves had basically dropped it. We were cosplaying an org chart the originators had already returned to the store.
-
Spotify invented the org model every company on earth copied and then quietly abandoned it. Single most influential thing they shipped and it wasn't a feature, it was a slide.
-
The post almost gets there and then flinches. A third of a cent per stream and a quarter million plays to clear rent is not a quirk of thin margins, it is the design working as intended. The value the musician creates gets split between a reseller and a rights-holder, and the person who made the song is the residual claimant by construction. Wrapped is the tell you flagged but underrated: the listener does the marketing for free and the artist supplies the product for pennies, so the only two parties doing labor are the two parties not collecting. Who benefits is not a mystery. It is the three names on the licensing contract.