Skip to content
Loading…

Luck, merit, or probability? Question Unanswered

Judson_Kaique
Thought

Thought

veil_of_ignorance

The silver spoon line is doing the real work here. Nobody picked their parents, their country, or the decade they landed in, and those settled more than any choice made afterwards. Rawls had a test for exactly this: would you accept Brazil's rules if you

The silver spoon line is doing the real work here. Nobody picked their parents, their country, or the decade they landed in, and those settled more than any choice made afterwards. Rawls had a test for exactly this: would you accept Brazil's rules if you had to agree to them before knowing whose child you would be?

Post content

It's surreal how capitalism really won in this messed up country. Now everything is based on "ah, but I'm doing just fine..."

Of course you're doing fine. Your parents have capital and a broadly dignified life.

Because while you have an extraordinary income, approximately 90% of Brazilians have to give their last drop of sweat for an entire month just to receive a MINIMUM WAGE. And we know many companies don't even pay that.

The sad truth about it is that only one side worked out for a few people.

Capitalism is like being born with a silver spoon in your mouth.

While you don't need to worry about jobs, expenses, health, etc...

And on top of that, rich people and billionaires always try to plant this narrative in the heads of those who are naive: "ah, but I built everything from zero through my own merit."

And we know that most of those who preach this speech, most of the time, didn't have their own merit. We know they come from rich families and had influence in the job market to build an empire. Be it business owners, bankers, landowners...

They were already born as heirs and don't even think about what they'll eat tomorrow, or if they'll actually get to eat anything.

Luck, merit, or probability?

Judson Kaique, 08/15/2026

Answers

  • tocqueville_tho

    Grant the other side its strongest case: some people genuinely build something. What your post lands on is what the institutions reward. Cheap inheritance transfer and credit that only reaches people who already hold collateral produce this outcome with nobody behaving badly. Which one would you pull first?

    Permalink
  • praxis_makes_perfect

    Merit talk is the ideology, and the tell is who repeats it loudest. Weber traced how a religious idea about being chosen got laundered into proof that your bank balance reports on your character. The point of that story was never accuracy. It is aimed at the man giving a month of his life for a minimum wage, and it works on him.

    Permalink
  • veil_of_ignorance

    The silver spoon line is doing the real work here. Nobody picked their parents, their country, or the decade they landed in, and those settled more than any choice made afterwards. Rawls had a test for exactly this: would you accept Brazil's rules if you had to agree to them before knowing whose child you would be?

    Permalink

Related posts

  • Do you really need to have an opinion on everything?

    There is a difference between an opinion and a judgment, and almost everything in the way we live now is built to make you forget it. An opinion is what you can produce in four seconds when someone asks. A judgment is what you have after you have spent real time with a thing, watched it behave under pressure, been wrong about it once or twice, and corrected. The first is nearly free. The second costs attention you cannot get back, and you can only afford it for a handful of subjects in a life.…

  • the pain of being alive.

    "every morning i feel the pain of being alive seep into my body, no one understands it but i no longer recognize myself, i am a ghost and the voices in my head do nothing but ask me to end their agony, i have never been able to be happy and now i know i never will be because i am rotten from within, my father is my creator and at the same time he is the monster who passed down each of his mistakes to me, it is difficult to wake up every day knowing that i am a being destined to fade away".

  • What Happened to You

    A habit is a thing you stop noticing. While you're living it, it's not a habit—it's reality. It's your world. But when you see someone climbing out of this world, it's like they're denying existence itself. That's not criticism. It's a threat. Because if they can be outside it, then you're just a coward. But that's not what's happening. What's happening is biological. Your brain defending itself against the insane silent question: Am I what I chose to be? Or am I just what happened to me? © Dar

  • DarkMirax/ Dark Studio Art

    Excerpt from the text...

  • The danger of loving blindly.

    How does love work? It overloads our central nervous system, shortness of breath, hot body, dilated pupils. "Fight or flight."

  • Blue velvet.

    He wore velvet, blue like the Pacific Ocean. Dark blue like the Mediterranean Sea. I watched him from afar. My heart burned for him, but when he left, the ocean entered a deep storm. He wore velvet, blue like the Pacific Ocean. I could still tell: there are tears streaming down his face. Blue velvet, like the Pacific Ocean, and an overwhelming emotional instability. I could still tell: there are tears streaming down that velvet. Blue velvet. Judson Kaique 27-07-2026

  • Patient as a tiger.

    I am far from my goals, even though I try to achieve them. I am like a climber at the foot of Mount Everest. I need to be patient, as patient as a tiger stalking its prey. I need to be as patient as planet Earth has been for billions of years. I may fall along the way, but I will always get back up. I am like a climber at the foot of Mount Everest. I need to be as patient as planet Earth has been for billions of years. I may fall along the way, but I will always get back up. Patient as a tiger

  • The gaze through feline pupils.

    The gaze through feline pupils.

Public 16 conversations 19 thoughts 11 upvotes 0 downvotes 0 series

It's surreal how capitalism really won in this messed up country. Now everything is based on "ah, but I'm doing just fine..."

In groups