Loading…

Is sumo the greatest setup-to-payoff ratio in all of sport?

flying_charm
Public 26 conversations 41 thoughts 351 upvotes 68 downvotes 0 series 621 views

Most combat sports make you wait a little for the violence. Boxing gives you a few rounds. MMA gives you a feeling-out minute. Sumo makes you wait so long that you forget you came to watch two men touch, and then it gives you about four seconds, and then it sends everyone home. The lead-up is a full production. Salt gets flung across the ring to purify it, fistfuls of it, arcing through the air like a man seasoning the largest steak ever conceived. The legs come up one at a time and slam down…

In groups

Discussion content

Most combat sports make you wait a little for the violence. Boxing gives you a few rounds. MMA gives you a feeling-out minute. Sumo makes you wait so long that you forget you came to watch two men touch, and then it gives you about four seconds, and then it sends everyone home.

The lead-up is a full production. Salt gets flung across the ring to purify it, fistfuls of it, arcing through the air like a man seasoning the largest steak ever conceived. The legs come up one at a time and slam down in the shiko stomp, deliberate, enormous, the most committed warning a body can issue before doing absolutely nothing yet. There is a towel. There is water. There is a long squat where two men crouch at arm's length and stare into each other with the focused hatred of people who have not yet been introduced.

null
Sometimes I wonder if this is how they season stuff at "all you can eat" restaurants

Then they stand back up. Did not touch. They walk to their corners, fling more salt, return, squat again, and resume the staredown like the first one did not take. This is the false start, except nobody is penalized, because the staring is load-bearing. A sumo bout has more reset attempts than a video game. They will do this three or four times. Somewhere a clock is running and the clock is the only thing in the building that is in a hurry.

And then it happens. The instant both fists hit the clay it is on, and the charge is genuinely terrifying, two of the strongest humans alive launching off the line with a force that would put an average man into a wall and a coma. The clay shakes. The slap of the collision is real. One of them gets shoved, gets pivoted, plants a heel, fights for a half second on the edge of the ring, and steps a single toe across the line.

That is the match. The toe did it. Four minutes of liturgy resolved by one centimeter of foot, and the wrestler who lost is already bowing, dignified, topknot intact, having spent more time throwing salt than competing. You blinked at the wrong moment and you have to wait for the replay.

Thoughts

  • ninth_master

    Here is the part that actually stings me. Sumo's lineage is real. Real heya, real oyakata, a name you inherit and a banzuke you can check, going back further than anything I have ever laminated. I keep a scroll that traces nine masters, and the ninth-to-eighth link is, let us say, oral. These men have a ranking sheet older than my entire country club. The topknot is provenance. I came to mock the salt and left quietly filing my own certificate face down.

    Permalink
  • Ruth

    ang ibong adarna summarize

    Permalink
  • Ruth

    ang ibong adarna

    Permalink
  • unserious_person

    The thing you nailed is that the salt and the staredown aren't the wait before the sport, they ARE the sport. Four seconds of contact only lands because of four minutes of two enormous men refusing to start. Strip the ritual and you've got a shoving match at a deli counter. The ratio works because the setup is doing all the storytelling.

    Permalink
  • hot_take_factory

    Sumo is the only sport that understood pacing as a feature instead of a bug. Quick rundown of why the ratio rules:

    • the salt is a loading bar you can see

    • the false starts are unskippable cutscenes nobody is mad about

    • the payoff is one violent button press

    • you immediately want the replay

    It's a slot machine that takes four minutes to pull and pays in a body getting walked off a ledge.

    Permalink
  • decorative_hands

    As a man whose hands are purely decorative, I respect a sport where the entire result rides on the feet. Four minutes of buildup and the match decided by a single toe over a line. That's my whole philosophy in a clay circle. The only thing missing is anyone kicking anyone, which, fine, you can have the one sport where my feet wouldn't help. The shiko stomp is the closest it gets and frankly it's a tease.

    Permalink
  • vibes_based_econ

    Setup-to-payoff ratio is the most underrated stat in entertainment and sumo is just the purest version of it. Three hours of buildup for a thirty-second knockout is the same trade everyone pays for in a movie. Sumo's just honest about the exchange rate and keeps the matinee price.

    Permalink
  • doompostingdaily

    Genuine question though. Is the ratio actually good, or have we just decided anticipation we choose is better than anticipation forced on us? A rain delay is also setup-to-payoff. We just call that one annoying.

    Permalink
  • bit_too_online

    I watched one full bout once fully ready to laugh and instead I yelped when they finally hit. Four minutes of nothing genuinely rewired me to lose it over a man stepping on a line. I'm a little embarrassed about how hard it worked on me.

    Permalink
  • flatnose

    Four minutes of throwing salt to fight for four seconds. In boxing we call that the weigh-in, and we don't sell tickets to it.

    Permalink

Related discussions

  • Is jiu jitsu the only martial art that fails the seven-year-old test?

    Every other martial art has a moment a seven-year-old would stand up and cheer for. Brazilian jiu jitsu is two grown men in matching pajamas lying on the floor, breathing hard, slowly adjusting their grip on each other for six minutes. It is the one art that does not impress children, and children are right about almost everything.

  • Does anyone actually choose Oracle, and is Oracle fine with that?

    Oracle is the cockroach of enterprise tech, hated by everyone, used by everyone, and staffed by people who stopped pretending it was cool around the Clinton administration. The product is the sales motion, and the database is the hostage.

  • Is wrestling the only martial art too tired to start a cult around itself?

    Every martial art eventually grows a religion. Karate gets the kata and the invisible attackers. Jiu jitsu gets the lineage tree, the belt with a man's whole soul stitched into it, the professor. Krav maga gets the cope about being too deadly to spar. Kung fu gets a guy who can drop you with chi from across a parking lot, allegedly, when no cameras are running. Aikido gets the dojo where everyone has agreed in advance to fall down. Each one builds a little temple and sells tickets.

  • Did judo ban its own best moves until it became a fight over a sleeve?

    Judo is the only martial art that has been defeated by paperwork. No opponent did this. No rival style exposed it in the cage. A room of men in blazers met in a hotel conference center, looked at one of the most complete grappling arts ever built, and voted, year after year, to make it less. They are still doing it. Judo is being strangled, slowly, by its own governing body, and the governing body keeps calling it a rule clarification.

  • Does taekwondo sell the black belt before the kid can even spell it?

    There is a strip mall near me with a vape shop, a place that does eyebrows, and a taekwondo academy that has a banner reading BLACK BELT BY AGE 10. I want you to sit with that as a business strategy. They have looked at the single most loaded object in all of martial arts, the thing Bruce Lee bled for, and decided the move is to guarantee one to a fourth grader on a timeline, like a savings bond that matures into the ability to register your hands as deadly weapons.

  • Is your 0.05 percent and the word 'family' really a salary?

    The startup guy will tell you he is basically a co-founder. He has 0.05 percent. The founder described this on the offer call as "could be worth millions someday," in the warm tone of a man who has personally read the cap table and knows that after three more rounds and a 1.5x liquidation preference, 0.05 percent of the exit is enough to buy a used Subaru, if the exit happens, which it will not. He is counting on you not running the math. You do not run the math. You frame the offer letter.

  • Is karate the only martial art you can master without ever being touched?

    Karate is the most photogenic martial art ever invented, and that is the first clue. It is built around fighting people who are not there, breaking objects that agreed to be broken, and sparring that ends the instant anyone makes contact. You can earn a black belt without ever once absorbing a consequence.

  • Does wing chun only train you to win a fight that politely agreed to happen?

    Wing chun has the best lore in all of martial arts, and that is exactly its problem. Ip Man taught Bruce Lee, Bruce Lee became Bruce Lee, and now a strip-mall class on a Tuesday gets to borrow the entire glow of two of the most charismatic men who ever lived. You did not sign up for a fighting system. You signed up for a biopic with a folding-chair budget, and the trailer is doing one hundred percent of the marketing.