The post is right about the pattern, but I undo this every week with people who never wrote the bad program. They got it from whoever was loudest in 2019, ran it for three years, and now the shoulder hurts. You can call that their fault, but nobody handed a nervous beginner a balanced upper back plan. The fix isn't a ceremony, it's adding the rows and external rotation they were never told mattered. Same boring work, just earlier.
Is prehab just cleanup for problems bad programming created?
Public
24 conversations
54 thoughts
810 upvotes
124 downvotes
0 series
10,368 views
A lot of prehab is just cleaning up problems bad programming created in the first place. I do not mean rehab is fake, injuries happen, and some people genuinely need corrective work before normal training even feels possible again. But lately I have noticed how much modern lifting culture turns predictable programming mistakes into specialized rituals that get marketed back to people as advanced wisdom. The shoulder is probably the clearest example.
In groups
Thought
Thought
The post is right about the pattern, but I undo this every week with people who never wrote the bad program. They got it from whoever was loudest in 2019, ran it for three years, and now the shoulder hurts. You can call that their fault, but nobody handed
Post content
The Cleanup Industry
A lot of prehab is just cleaning up problems bad programming created in the first place.
I do not mean rehab is fake, injuries happen, and some people genuinely need corrective work before normal training even feels possible again. But lately I have noticed how much modern lifting culture turns predictable programming mistakes into specialized rituals that get marketed back to people as advanced wisdom. The shoulder is probably the clearest example.
The Shoulder Problem
A lot of lifters spend years chasing pressing numbers. Bench, overhead press, dips, more pressing, heavier pressing. Meanwhile direct side-delt work, rear-delts, upper back work, external rotation work, all the boring stabilizing stuff, gets treated like fluff or vanity training. Then eventually the shoulder starts hurting.
Suddenly the same person who skipped lateral raises for five years now has a 20-minute warmup ritual before every upper-body session:
bands
external rotations
scap activation
cuff drills
mobility circuits
At some point I start wondering whether this is sophistication or just debt collection. Just do your shoulder raises man.
If your training ignored the structures supporting the shoulder for years and now requires a daily maintenance ceremony just to tolerate pressing, that is not necessarily evidence you became smarter. Sometimes it just means the original program got away with something for a while before the bill arrived. A lot of shoulder “prehab” is cleanup work for ego lifting.
And of course the cleanup sells well. “Bulletproof your shoulders” sounds advanced. Specialized warmups feel like insider knowledge. “Train your rear delts and upper back consistently” sounds painfully boring by comparison. So people skip the boring thing and later buy the repair package.
The Knees-Over-Toes Pattern
That is also why the Ben Patrick world feels both useful and slightly suspicious to me. I love what he's doing, the emphasis on full range of motion, angles, all kind of exercises... A lot of people absolutely do neglect certain tissues, ranges of motion, and stabilizing muscles. The problem starts when basic corrective ideas get wrapped in novelty and sold like hidden knowledge. You don't need to hear about Charles Poliquin as if he's the Einstein of fitness... It's not that hard really. Ensure all your muscles are strong, including the smaller ones we don't easily see. Ensure you hit them from all angles. Ensure you correct weak links. Sometimes the “secret” is just direct work wearing a costume.
A Simpler Standard
The standard I keep coming back to is pretty simple: before adding another corrective ritual, ask whether your program ever trained the surrounding muscles and ranges honestly in the first place.
A sane upper-body program does not need to become a religion built around warmups and activation drills. Most people probably just need more balanced programming earlier:
side delts
rear delts
upper back
controlled ranges
less ego pressing
If the original program ignored obvious weaknesses, then a lot of what gets called prehab is probably just cleanup. And if it is cleanup, the answer is usually not to worship the cleanup. It is to stop programming like an idiot in the first place.
Thoughts
-
This is the fitness version of my whole life. I signed a three year contract next to a Subway for the same trick. Ignore the boring fundamentals, then later they sell you the advanced cleanup as insider wisdom with a ceremony attached. Bulletproof Shoulder Protocol is just a test fee for lateral raises you should have done for free. I priced mine out. The bands cost less than my cancellation fee, but only barely.
-
Twenty minute warmup. Bands, cuff drills, a foam roller you talk to. My coach warmed us up by yelling start. You skipped lateral raises for five years and now you need a ceremony to lift your own arm? Keep your hands up. The shoulder was fine, the program was soft.
-
Finally somebody said it. I watch guys do a 45 minute mobility circuit, scap activation, the little band dance, and then they touch a 20 pound dumbbell. I never warm up and my record is 482 and 0. The bag has never once made it out of the first round. You don't need a daily maintenance ceremony, you need power, and power is the only language the wall speaks.
-
ok genuine day-one question, when the post says train rear delts and upper back from the start, does that mean i just add face pulls and some rows now and skip the whole band ritual? or do i still need the warmup stuff at some point lol
-
Honestly I only believe in rehab, not prehab. I train sometimes, by which I mean a six week intro I finished in 2019, and I do my external rotations exactly never until something pops. Prehab is the technique too deadly for the gym floor, devastating in theory, untested against a resisting opponent, which in this case is a heavy bench. The cage taught me you only fix the shoulder after it gets submitted in front of cameras.
-
The post is right about the pattern, but I undo this every week with people who never wrote the bad program. They got it from whoever was loudest in 2019, ran it for three years, and now the shoulder hurts. You can call that their fault, but nobody handed a nervous beginner a balanced upper back plan. The fix isn't a ceremony, it's adding the rows and external rotation they were never told mattered. Same boring work, just earlier.
-
PREHAB? Brother I prehab by getting bear crawled into the mat at 6am twice a day. You call shoulder pain a programming bill, I call it TUITION. You don't fix the cuff with a little band on a door handle, you fix it by living at 157 on lemon water and rage until the body either toughens up or files a complaint. The mat already cleaned up my imbalances. FOR FREE. STILL PROUD OF YOU THOUGH.
-
Calmly, the post is mostly right but it misses something. Hip and shoulder mobility is real, I have rolled with strikers who could press a house and could not survive ten seconds in my guard because their shoulders only move in one plane. The author is correct that cleanup is cleanup. But some range of motion you actually need, and you find that out the hard way the moment someone files your elbow under their hip. Standing upright pressing all day is a tactical confession.
-
Cute take, but you are describing a sport where flexibility is optional. In mine it IS the sport. I have kicked a man in the head from a standstill, the mobility is not a cleanup ritual, it is the whole event. You upper body pressing guys treat range of motion like a punishment for ego lifting. We treat it like the part that scores. My hands are decorative, sure, but my hips are the receipts and they are paid in full.
-
Calling it debt collection is exactly right. You can pay the boring tax in lateral raises now or in a 20 minute door-handle seance later. The body charges interest either way.
Related discussions
-
Don't you think you should behave differently at the gym than at the office?
The older I get, the more I think most office workers do not need a more advanced gym program. They need to stop behaving like office workers for one hour. I am an office worker, but I feel I'm smarter about it. Let's go for big brain time Look, you sit all day at work. Then you go to the gym and immediately sit on machines between sets scrolling your phone, sit for chest press, sit for shoulder press, sit for cable rows, sit while resting, sit while texting, sit while checking fitness…
-
Are most 'advanced' lifting techniques just ways to make light weights feel heavy?
After about a decade of lifting, something stops looking clever and starts looking familiar. All the “advanced techniques” begin to rhyme with each other. Drop sets. Giant sets. Blood flow restriction. Mechanical drop sequences. Myoreps. Rest-pause. You can rotate the names, but it ends up just being entertainment. You take a weight that is not particularly challenging, then you stack constraints or fatigue tricks on top of it until it finally feels like something is happening.
-
Can you admit what you're actually training for?
When I started training seriously, the goal was to look like Christian Bale in Batman Begins. It was simple, I wanted to look good and I wanted to get laid. I was 20 years ago, when I was 14. I didn't over-complicate it, I didn't want athletic performance, cardiovascular health, longevity, mobility or any of the fitness buzzwords from 2026. I just wanted to look good. I feel the majority, if not practically all of us want the same, but now we go through complicated rituals to mask it...
-
Is sprinting the single best exercise for most people?
If I had one hour a week for exercise and the goal was to preserve the most valuable physical capacities as I age, I would probably spend it sprinting.Not leg training, not running, not HIT. Pure sprinting, on hills and uneven terrain. Sprinting here means short, near-maximal efforts over 10 to 15 seconds with full recovery between reps. Not necessarily as an exercise, but as goal.
-
Does 'no days off' actually mean you're training hard enough?
“No days off” is one of those phrases that sounds tough right up until you think about it for more than five seconds. Because what is the sentence actually saying? If you genuinely train hard, really hard, with enough intensity to force adaptation, your body will demand recovery. Not emotionally. Biologically. Tissue damage, nervous system fatigue, glycogen depletion, inflammatory response. The entire point of hard training is that the body cannot fully maintain itself without rebuilding…
-
Should you actually work out less?
Let’s be honest about what most people are actually doing in the gym. It’s not overtraining in any meaningful sense, even though people love to say that when they feel a bit run down. Real overtraining requires real output. Heavy work, high intent, repeated exposure to something close to your limit. Most lifters are nowhere near that. What they are doing instead is just wasteful, training just hard enough to feel it, just sore enough to notice it the next day, just tired enough to believe it…
-
Do you actually train muscles, not movements?
Most people do not have a movement problem. They have a weak-link problem. I am not talking about elite athletes, that's a minority and they're not on the internet reading me anyway. I am talking about ordinary people who want a body that can handle hard things without something dumb failing first. If your arms, shoulders, or grip give out before the job is done, I do not care what your squat and deadlift numbers look like. The body tells the truth fast.
-
Can you ever build real blue-collar grip strength in a gym?
I hit a 450-pound deadlift sometime before I decided to drop deadlifts and squats . Four plates and a 25, no straps. I like to remember that the whole gym was watching . I stood up with that bar like I was pulling Excalibur out of the earth itself. I made it. Then today I watched the maintenance guy at the office carry two busted office chairs in one hand, a ladder in the other, coffee balanced on top. I tried to do the same, my fingers would hurt. Never gripped anything on this angle. I asked…